How to write an adjudication charter
Every clinical events committee runs on a charter: the document that defines what the committee reviews, how members decide, and what happens when they disagree. Charters are usually written carefully and approved early. But a charter that reads well in a document doesn't always work well on case number 214 at the end of a long day.
The test of a good charter is whether reviewers applying it to real cases reach consistent, well-documented decisions. That depends less on length than on whether every rule can be turned into something concrete: a field on a form, an option in a list, a step in the routing.
Start with the decisions, not the background
Charters often open with pages of background on the trial and the committee's role. That context matters, but the most important section is the one that answers: what exactly must a reviewer decide for each case?
For each event type, write down:
- the question being answered (for example, "Does this event meet the protocol definition of a major adverse event?");
- the allowed answers, as a closed list;
- any follow-up questions that depend on the answer (for example, relatedness to the device or procedure, if the event is confirmed);
- what written rationale is required.
If you can't list the answers, reviewers won't give consistent ones.
Write definitions that can be applied, not just understood
Event definitions are where most inconsistency starts. A definition that experts broadly agree with can still be applied differently in edge cases.
A few habits help:
- Use the protocol's wording, and make sure the charter, protocol, and statistical analysis plan define each endpoint the same way.
- Spell out thresholds and time windows, such as how long after the procedure an event must occur to count.
- Say what to do with incomplete information. Can a reviewer classify an event as "unable to determine"? If so, when?
- Include worked examples for common borderline cases, agreed by the committee chair before review starts.
Separate medical judgment from data checks
Not every criterion needs a physician. Some, such as a lab value above a cutoff or a visit outside a date window, can be checked objectively from the data. Others need clinical interpretation.
A good charter says which is which. Criteria that need medical judgment go to reviewers. Objective ones are handled by data management and stay off the review form. That keeps reviewers focused on the decisions only they can make, shortens each review, and avoids reviewers re-deriving numbers that are already in the database.
Define the path from disagreement to a final answer
Charters should never leave disagreement to be sorted out informally. Write the route down step by step:
- How many independent reviewers assess each case.
- What counts as agreement, and whether every field must match or only the primary classification.
- Who breaks a tie, and whether that reviewer sees the earlier determinations.
- When a case goes to the full committee, and what quorum is needed to decide it.
- How the committee's decision is recorded and by whom.
If you can draw it as a flowchart with no "it depends" boxes, it can be applied the same way every time.
Plan for change before it happens
Sites update data after events have been adjudicated. Protocols get amended. Committee members leave. A charter that only describes the steady state will be stretched by all of these.
Decide in advance:
- what happens when source data change after a final decision, and whether the case is re-reviewed in full or only for the changed information;
- how charter amendments take effect, and whether cases already adjudicated are revisited;
- how new members are trained and when they get access.
Make the charter the form
The most reliable way to make sure a charter is followed is to build it directly into the review workflow. Each decision becomes a required field. Each closed list becomes the only set of options. The disagreement rules become automatic routing. Training then covers how to use the form, and the form enforces the charter.
That is how studies are set up in Reviewr™: forms, decision options, and consensus routing configured around each study's protocol and charter, with live reviewer training before anyone gets access. If you are drafting a charter now, we can help you check how it will work in practice.